This is a great dish to make for company -- it feeds a lot of people you can prep it the night before, and it roasts low and slow all day until you are ready to serve it. When it's done, the meat just falls off the bone when prodded with a fork, and it's as juicy and flavorful as anything you've ever eaten.
1 pork shoulder (approx 9 pounds, either bone in or boneless is fine, but the bone does impart more flavor to the meat)
Kosher salt
Dried Oregano
Black Pepper
Smashed garlic cloves.
Take your pork shoulder and trim off any big chunks of fat, but don't worry about getting all of it or doing a pretty job of it -- it will all dissolve into the meat during the cooking process.
Make 6-8 slits in each side of the meat and put a smashed garlic clove or two into each of the slits.
Make a mixture that is approximately 1 tablespoon pepper, 3 tablespoons of salt, and 6 tablespoons dried oregano and slather it all over the pork shoulder, patting it into the meat. If you have an "Italian Mix" of herbs that you want to use instead of the oregano, that's fine too.
Place the meat into a roasting pan, cover tightly with aluminum foil, and refrigerate overnight.
The next day, put the covered pan into a 250 degree oven and cook for about 3 or 4 hours. Then uncover the pork and turn your oven up to 300 degrees. Every 45 minutes or so, baste the pork roast with its juices (they will be plentiful!) After 3 hours, pull at the shoulder with a fork to confirm that the meat comes off easily. If it doesn't, cook for another hour or so.
Remove the pork from the oven about 30 minutes before serving and wrap up the shoulder tightly in a couple of layers of aluminum foil. You can also cover it with a few towels to help keep it nice and warm.
Strain all the juices into a bowl and in about 10 minutes, skim off all the fat and the scum that rises to the top.
When ready to serve, use large serving forks to pull all the meat off into chunks and place them on your serving platter. If the meat in the center needs a little nudge with a carving knife, that's fine too. Then splash all the meat with the pork juices, sprinkle with a little salt if desired, and serve.
I promise you'll earn rave reviews for this.